When is a homicide not a homicide?
This post was originally published on the website of InsightCrime with the title El Salvador to Omit Key Data From Official Homicide Tally
By Parker Asmann
The government of El Salvador says that homicide data will only include “social violence” and not instances involving confrontations with security forces, a move that makes it difficult to accurately analyze the country’s precarious security situation.
El Salvador’s national police explained to President Nayib Bukele that the homicides registered in the country will no longer include victims of alleged confrontations between security forces and suspected gang members, nor those found dead and buried in graves, El Mundo reported.
In the first 45 days of the Bukele administration, 35 suspected gang members have been killed in alleged confrontations with security forces — 22 in June and 13 in the first 15 days of July. Such incidents will no longer be included in the daily tally of violent deaths, according to El Diario de Hoy.
The clarification came as police forces presented a report on the homicides committed during the first 25 days of a security plan that sent police and soldiers into the streets to retake territory dominated by the MS13 and Barrio 18 gangs.
In addition to the 2,500 officers and 3,000 soldiers sent to the capital San Salvador and other city centers as part of the operation, another 2,000 soldiers will be deployed by year’s end to try and regain control in the country’s 14 departmental capitals.
El Salvador’s homicide rate has been trending downward in recent years. While still one of Latin America’s most violent nations, the 3,340 homicides recorded in 2018 represented a 15 percent drop from the 3,947 homicides recorded in 2017.
By Parker Asmann
The government of El Salvador says that homicide data will only include “social violence” and not instances involving confrontations with security forces, a move that makes it difficult to accurately analyze the country’s precarious security situation.
El Salvador’s national police explained to President Nayib Bukele that the homicides registered in the country will no longer include victims of alleged confrontations between security forces and suspected gang members, nor those found dead and buried in graves, El Mundo reported.
In the first 45 days of the Bukele administration, 35 suspected gang members have been killed in alleged confrontations with security forces — 22 in June and 13 in the first 15 days of July. Such incidents will no longer be included in the daily tally of violent deaths, according to El Diario de Hoy.
The clarification came as police forces presented a report on the homicides committed during the first 25 days of a security plan that sent police and soldiers into the streets to retake territory dominated by the MS13 and Barrio 18 gangs.
In addition to the 2,500 officers and 3,000 soldiers sent to the capital San Salvador and other city centers as part of the operation, another 2,000 soldiers will be deployed by year’s end to try and regain control in the country’s 14 departmental capitals.
El Salvador’s homicide rate has been trending downward in recent years. While still one of Latin America’s most violent nations, the 3,340 homicides recorded in 2018 represented a 15 percent drop from the 3,947 homicides recorded in 2017.
InSight Crime Analysis
The Bukele administration’s decision to report incomplete homicide data appears to be a clear attempt to either paint a rosy picture of a security situation it is still trying to get under control, or to hide potential abuses carried out by the country’s security forces.
El Salvador’s security forces have a proven track record of using excessive and often lethal force. In 2017, it was revealed that a death squad-style special police unit used social media to coordinate at least three extrajudicial killings of suspected gang members. The following year, intercepted telephone conversations uncovered that high-ranking members of the country’s military commanded a clandestine death squad that executed alleged gang members.
In the past, the United States has provided funding to such elite units accused of committing egregious abuses of force.
In addition, the new methodology for counting homicides won’t include incidents like the infamous March 2015 police massacre at the San Blas farm. The police claim an “exchange of fire” led to the killing of eight alleged gang members. But the facts showed the men were executed and arranged to make it appear as if they had died in a shootout with police.
And while homicides may be on the decline in El Salvador, disappearances are up. The 3,514 disappearance cases registered by the Attorney General’s Office in 2018 were more than the number of homicides recorded that year. Those later found to be dead, including in clandestine graves — a tactic used by the country’s gangs in the past — would not be included under the government’s new homicide records.
What’s more, the new guidelines could create a nightmare situation where homicides recorded by the Bukele administration differ significantly from the data collected by the country’s medical examiners or the Attorney General’s Office. Such conflicting numbers would make it very difficult to develop a complete understanding of any potential homicide trends, potentially stalling effective policies to curb violence and insecurity, among other obstacles.
The Bukele administration’s decision to report incomplete homicide data appears to be a clear attempt to either paint a rosy picture of a security situation it is still trying to get under control, or to hide potential abuses carried out by the country’s security forces.
El Salvador’s security forces have a proven track record of using excessive and often lethal force. In 2017, it was revealed that a death squad-style special police unit used social media to coordinate at least three extrajudicial killings of suspected gang members. The following year, intercepted telephone conversations uncovered that high-ranking members of the country’s military commanded a clandestine death squad that executed alleged gang members.
In the past, the United States has provided funding to such elite units accused of committing egregious abuses of force.
In addition, the new methodology for counting homicides won’t include incidents like the infamous March 2015 police massacre at the San Blas farm. The police claim an “exchange of fire” led to the killing of eight alleged gang members. But the facts showed the men were executed and arranged to make it appear as if they had died in a shootout with police.
And while homicides may be on the decline in El Salvador, disappearances are up. The 3,514 disappearance cases registered by the Attorney General’s Office in 2018 were more than the number of homicides recorded that year. Those later found to be dead, including in clandestine graves — a tactic used by the country’s gangs in the past — would not be included under the government’s new homicide records.
What’s more, the new guidelines could create a nightmare situation where homicides recorded by the Bukele administration differ significantly from the data collected by the country’s medical examiners or the Attorney General’s Office. Such conflicting numbers would make it very difficult to develop a complete understanding of any potential homicide trends, potentially stalling effective policies to curb violence and insecurity, among other obstacles.
This post was originally published on the website of InsightCrime with the title El Salvador to Omit Key Data From Official Homicide Tally
Comments
All homicides (murders) are homicides.
Under law (in general) a homicide is considered justified based on if specific circumstances and conditions are met, and in the case of the military or law enforcement those laws, policies, and procedures are shown to have been met/applied in good faith.
I would imagine there is more to the President's decision making process than what the Media can capture and properly analyze/publish.
He has promised tangible action and it appears that is what he is delivering.